The morphological differences among the Udyn Sayr specimens may indicate intraspecific variation of Protoceratops. Literally. At least 8 body fossils of Protoceratops present active teeth marks, which were interpreted as feeding traces. However, it is now believed that they cathemeral. [68], However, in 2011 Lars Schmitz and Ryosuke Motani measured the dimensions of the sclerotic ring and eye socket in fossils specimens of dinosaurs and pterosaurs, as well as some living species. Based on comparisons with other ornithischian dinosaurs such as Maiasaura and Orodromeusknown from more complete nestsThulborn concluded that most depictions of Protoceratops nests were based on incompletely preserved clutches and mostly on type A eggs, which were more likely to have been laid by an ornithopod. The fact that the individuals likely spend some time in the nest after hatching for growth suggests that Protoceratops parents might have cared for their young at nests during at least the early stages of life. The first metatarsal and toe were the smallest, while the other elements were of similar shape and length. [5][19], The lower jaw of Protoceratops was a large element composed of the predentary, dentary, coronoid, angular and surangular. [5], In 1963, the Mongolian paleontologist Demberelyin Dashzeveg reported the discovery of a new fossiliferous locality of the Djadokhta Formation: Tugriken Shireh. The difference in morphologies between Protoceratops also suggests that the nearby Bayan Mandahu Formation is slightly younger than the Djadokhta Formation. . The flexed position of most buried Protoceratops is indicative of desiccation and shrinking of ligaments/tendons in the legs, necks, and tails after death. [64], In 2018 paleontologists ucja Fostowicz-Frelik and Justyna Sowiak studied the bone histology of several specimens of P. andrewsi through cross-sections, in order to analyze the growth changes in this dinosaur. As some individuals are closely appressed along the well-defined margin of the nest, it may have had a circular or semi-circular shapeas previously hypothetizedwith a diameter of 70cm (700mm). However, they suggested that authentic differences between sexes could be still present in the postcranial skeleton. In a top view they had a triangular shape and were joined by the frontals (bones of the skull roof). Protoceratops (/protosrtps/; lit. Thanks to the large collection of skulls found in the expeditions, they concluded that Protoceratops represented a ceratopsian more primitive than ceratopsids and not an ankylosaur-ceratopsian ancestor. Protoceratops Protoceratops ("Before the horned-faces") is well known from numerous skeletons, ranging from young animals to adults. [73], Peter Dodson in 1996 used anatomical characters of the skull in P. andrewsi in order to quantify areas subject to ontogenic changes and sexual dimorphism. Protoceratops was a primitive ceratopsian, about the size of a sheep, that lived in the prehistoric Gobi desert at least 75 million years ago. [82], In 2010 David Hone with team reported a new interaction between Velociraptor and Protoceratops based on tooth marks. Barsbold suggested that both animals drowned as they fell into a swamp-like body of water or, the relatively quicksand-like bottom of a lake could have kept them together during the last moments of their fight. Velociraptor, facts and photos. Tereshchenko using speed equations also estimated the average maximum walking speed of Protoceratops at about 3km/h (kilometres per hour). Handa and team in addition found variation across this Udyn Sayr sample and classified them in three groups. A dinosaur habitat right next to rivers are floodplains. The first point was supported by the numerous anatomical differences between protoceratopsids and psittacosaurids, most notably the extreme reduction of some hand digits in the latter groupa trait much less pronounced in protoceratopsids. [66], Upon the analysis of the forelimbs of several ceratopsians, Phil Senter in 2007 suggested that the hands of Protoceratops could reach the ground when the hindlimbs were upright, and the overall forelimb morphology and range of motion may reflect that it was at least a facultative (optional) quadruped. The formation is known for its vertebrate fossils in life-like poses, most of which are preserved in unstructured sandstone, indicating a catastrophic rapid burial. All teeth had a single root (lower part inserted in the alveoli). Protoceratops belonged to the group of Ceratopsians (Ceratopians) 5. Protoceratops. [97] Dominant sediments at Djadokhta include dominant reddish-orange and pale orange to light gray, medium to fine-grained sands and sandstones, caliche, and sparse fluvial (river-deposited) processes. It was believed that the discovery of a small, herbivorous dinosaur named Protoceratops was the inspiration for the creation of the iconic griffin, a belief challenged in 2016 by paleontologist Mark Witton. |intraspecific variation]] within Protoceratops, and they differ from other populations across the Djadokhta Formation (like Tugriken Shireh), being unique to the Udyn Sayr region. Ceratopsia or Ceratopia ("horned faces") is a group of herbivorous, beaked dinosaurs which thrived in what are now North America and Asia, during the Cretaceous Period, although ancestral forms lived earlier, in the Jurassic. Found as fossils in deposits from the Late Cretaceous Period (about 100 million to 65.5 million years ago) of eastern Asia and North America, Oviraptor was about 1.8 metres (6 feet) long and walked on two long, well-developed hind limbs. [100] P. andrewsi is also abundant at Udyn Sayr,[76][56] where Avimimus and Udanoceratops have been recovered. Facts on the Protoceratops. Because Protoceratops is considered to have been a herding animal, another hypothesis is that members of a herd tried to pull out the already buried Protoceratops, causing the joint dislocation of limbs. [118], In 1993 Jerzykiewiczz suggested that many articulated Protoceratops specimens died in the process of trying to free themselves from massive sand bodies that trapped them during sandstorms events and were not transported by environmental factors. The AMNH is the best place to see it in the Americas, with a tableaux of a couple at a nesting sight and a rather famous skull growth series along the wall next to it. Even though their respective skull anatomy had substantial differences, their postcranial skeleton was virtually the same. Given that the Velociraptor is relatively complete, Carpenter suggested that it may have been completely or partially buried by sand. The foremost hole, the nares (nostril opening), was oval-shaped and considerably smaller than the nostrils seen in ceratopsids. Later members, including ceratopsids like Centrosaurus and Triceratops, became very large quadrupeds and . [47] The fossilized footprint associated with the specimen ZPAL Mg D-II/3 described by Niedwiedzki in 2012 indicates that Protoceratops was digitigrade, meaning that it walked with its toes supporting the body weight. Despite maintaining the skull morphology of most Protoceratops specimens (such as premaxillary teeth), the neck frill in this population was straighter with a near triangular shape. The researchers focused on the mineral and chemical compositions of the . The co-workers also noted that the Fox Site Protoceratops preserves associated traces in the encasing sediment, indicative of necrophagous activity after the animal was buried. andrewsi (Granger and Gregory, 1923) juveniles in situ from from MPC-D 100/530. Story. The radius had a slightly recurved shape and was longer than the ulna. The first five cervical ribs (sometimes called chevrons) were some of the shortest ribs, and among them the first two were longer than the rest. [18], In 2001 Oliver Lambert with colleagues named a new and distinct species of Protoceratops, P. hellenikorhinus. Several fossils were collected at the Gate locality of the Bayan Mandahu Formation in 2008, including teeth and body remains of protoceratopsid and velociraptorine dinosaurs. In 1971, the expedition explored several localities of the Djadokhta and Nemegt formations. The ischium was the longest bone of the pelvic girdle. The researchers analyzed new, embryo-bearing egg fossils ascribed to the dinosaurs Protoceratops and Mussaurus. [78], In 2020 nevertheless, Andrew C. Knapp and team conducted morphometric analyses of a large sample of P. andrewsi specimens, primarily confluding that the neck frill of Protoceratops has no indicators or evidence for being sexually dimorphic. The jugal bones also showed a trend towards an increase in relative size. The type species is Coahuilaceratops magnacuerna. Like Triceratops, its North American relative, Protoceratops walked on 4 legs, was heavily built, and had a parrot-like beak. They also named the new genus and species of protoceratopsid Bagaceratops rozhdestvenskyi, known from specimens of the nearby Hermiin Tsav locality. . The ulna was a rather short bone with a straight shape. Though more remains of Protoceratops were collected in later years of the expeditions, they were most abundant in the 1922 to 1925 seasons. The individuals of this block were identified as a P. andrewsi and V. mongoliensis. [6] In 1951 Edwin H. Colbert considered Protoceratops to represent a key ancestor for the ceratopsid lineage, suggesting that it ultimately led to the evolution of large-bodied ceratopsians such as Styracosaurus and Triceratops. The rostral bone was devoid of teeth, high and triangular in shape. They interpreted the interaction as the Protoceratops being grasped and dispatched with kicks delivered by the low-lying Velociraptor. 'first horned face') is a genus of small protoceratopsid dinosaurs that lived in Asia during the Late Cretaceous, around 75 to 71 million years ago.The genus Protoceratops includes two species: P. andrewsi and the larger P. hellenikorhinus.The former was described in 1923 with fossils from the Mongolian Djadokhta Formation, and the . a, b, Clutch assigned to the basal ceratopsian Protoceratops (a) on the basis of embryonic remains (b).The white outlined area in a corresponds to b; the arrow in b indicates one of the white, egg . The use of the frill as a displaying structure may be related to other anatomical features of Protoceratops such as the premaxillary teeth (at least for P. andrewsi) which could have been used in display or intraspecific combat, or the high neural spines of tail. The coracoids were relatively elliptical, and sometimes coosified (fused) to the scapulae. When the type fossil of Oviraptor was unearthed, in 1923, it was sitting atop a clutch of fossilized eggsprompting the theory that it had just raided a Protoceratops nest. Protoceratops is one of the most common dinosaurs from its habitat and region which, along with its size, has given it the nickname "Sheep of the Cretaceous". Ceratopsians (including protoceratopsids), along with Euoplocephalus, Hungarosaurus, parkosaurid, ornithopod and heterodontosaurine dinosaurs, were found to be in the former category, indicating that Protoceratops and relatives had strong bite forces and relied mostly on its jaws to process food. The white arrow indicates a broken rib, and the black arrows point to pterosaur bones preserved inside the dinosaur's . [33][34][35], During the Third Central Asiatic Expedition in 1923, a nearly complete Protoceratops skeleton (specimen AMNH 6418) was collected at the Flaming Cliffs. The first block (MPC-D 100/526) comprises four juvenile individuals in close proximity with their heads pointing upwards, and the second block (MPC-D 100/534) is composed of two sub-adults with a horizontal orientation. Since this event likely occurred after the death of both animals or during a point where movement was not possible, and the Protoceratops is missing other body elements, Barsbold suggested that scavengers were the most likely authors. Fastovsky and team also suggested that even though the individuals were young, they were not perinates based on the absence of eggshell fragments and their large size compared to even more smaller juveniles from this locality.